High-school seniors have a lot on their minds these
days-applying to college, getting accepted, finding the funds to
pay for it, then worrying about whether they can get a job once
they graduate. One thing they hadn't counted on, however, was
being drafted into the military when they turn 18.
There hasn't been a draft in the United States since 1973, but
indications are strong that next year that may change. And for
the first time, young women as well as men can expect to be
called.
Why a return to the draft? Because our troops (stationed in
two-thirds of the world's countries) are spread so thinly, and
because high casualty rates in Iraq and Afghanistan have
dramatically reduced recruitment and reenlistment levels. A poll
taken last year by Stars and Stripes, a Pentagon-funded
newspaper for service personnel, found that 49 percent of
respondents were not planning to reenlist.
According to retired U.S. Army Colonel David Hackworth, a
military analyst and one of the most decorated officers in the
army, the U.S. military is now so shorthanded that a whop- ping
40 percent of the 135,000 troops being rotated into Iraq are
National Guard members and reservists. Adds Congressman Charles
Rangel (D-NY), "We haven't called up this level of reservists
since the Korean War."
What's more, if House and Bills HR163 and S89 pass, the hole of
college, used by many to avoid serving in Vietnam, will be
closed next time around. All men and women ages 18 to 26 would
be eligible for induction once they have completed high school.
Further, the Smart Border Declaration, signed by Canadian and
U.S. officials in December 2001, should keep would-be draft
dodgers in this country.
Congressman Rangel, author of the House bill, which is now
before the Armed Services Committee (Ernest Hollings [D-SCJ
authored the Senate version), explains that the Administration's
commitment to a prolonged presence in the Middle East, the
prospect of additional military interventions, and the fact that
"half of Guards and reservists say they have no intention to
stay in" are strong indicators that "ultimately we will run out
of bodies."
"We shouldn't need a draft," says Rangel, "but now that we've
been involved in a war, the patriotic thing is shared sacrifice.
Currently, the rich get a tax cut, and the poor get a chance to
make the ultimate sacrifice."
Senator Chuck Hagel (R-NE), addressing the Senate Foreign
Relations Committee in April, concurred. "Why shouldn't we ask
all our citizens to bear some responsibility and pay some
price?" he said.
Feeling a Draft?
The Administration denies that a draft is in the works.
Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld has stated: "We're not
going to reemployment a draft. There is no need for it . The
disadvantages of using compulsion to bring into the armed forces
the men and women needed are notable."
But, says Ron Paul, M.D., an eight-term Republican congressman
from Texas and a former Air Force surgeon, "You don't listen to
what they say, you watch what they do. The Administration says
no, but what we've gotten from the Pentagon and elsewhere is
yes."
One sign of that, says Rick Jahnkow, program coordinator of the
nonprofit Project on Youth and Non-Military Opportunities, was
that last fall "[Presidential adviser] Karl Rove polled
Republican members of Congress on how Illey felt about the
draft. They said they'd support the President"
"This is not surprising," comments Dr. Paul, who sits on the
International Relations Committee and was one of only six
Republican congressmen who voted against the war in Iraq. "Our
foreign policy involves us in so much around the world. To
continue to do this, we need more troops." He further points out
that we already have a "de facto draft. You only have to look at
how the Administration has refused to allow troops to end their
tours of duty when their contracts are up," he says.
The Administration is in a box, observes Ned Lebow, Ph.D.,
presidential professor of government at Dartmouth College and a
former professor of military strategy at the National War and
Naval Colleges. "The Pentagon has tried to resolve its serious
manpower shortages in Iraq by greatly extending tours of duty.
Reservists and Guards can be kept in for as long as the
government says they need them, possibly for years, and this has
become increasingly un- acceptable in the political sense at
home."
Playing with Numbers?
When FAMILY CIRCLE interviewed Col. Hackworth in late March, he
said, "Our armed forces have had more than 600 fatalities in
Iraq and 14,000 casualties." Hackworth's figures, which he
received from a senior Pentagon source, were more than four
times higher than the statistics then posted on the Web site of
the Department of Defense. And Stars and Stripes reported
that the Landstuhl Military Hospital in Germany had treated
three times more casualties from Iraq than the Pentagon had
posted. Says Col. Hackworth, "A lot of lying goes on about
casualty rates. Both the Pentagon and the officers in the field
lied about the number of our Vietnam casualties. If a wounded
serviceman died in a helicopter while being evacuated for
medical treatment, for example, he wasn't listed as a combat
death." (As we went to press, reported fatalities in Iraq were
at 765 and climbing, and casualties had increased significantly
as well.)
Will They or Won't They?
Rumblings about a new draft began last fall when the Defense
Department's Web site posted an ad exhorting Americans over 18
to "Serve Your Community and the Nation, Become a Selective
Service System Local Board Member."
If a military draft is activated, approximately 2,000 local and
appeal boards will decide who gets deferments, postponements or
exemptions from service. The Pentagon has now removed the notice
from its Web site and denies any move to reinstate the draft,
stating that the Selective Service System, which runs the draft
boards, is merely launching a routine recruitment drive as 80
percent of those jobs are now vacant.
The SSS does admit, however, that it is planning for a possible
draft of Arabic linguists, computer experts and medical
personnel-doctors, nurses and technicians, ages 20 to 44. The
last time physicians were drafted was during the Vietnam War.
"We began working on scenarios for this after receiving a
request for people with these skills from the Department of
Defense," says SSS spokeswoman Alyce Burton.
According to the Selective Service Annual Performance Plan for
2004, before next March 31 draft boards must be potentially
operational within two and a half months of a return to
conscription. The plan also calls for testing the draft lottery,
examination system and the system that classifies, places and
monitors conscientious objectors.
No Child Left Unrecruited?
The United States spends $3 billion annually on military
recruiting. What is not commonly known is that a great deal of
that money is spent in our schools. The No Child Left Behind
Act, signed by President Bush two years ago, includes a
provision that if secondary schools fail to release the names,
addresses and phone numbers of students to military recruiters,
they will lose their Federal funding. Schools must allow
military recruiters the same access to students received by
civilian recruiters and colleges.
Jahnkow reports that high-school juniors and seniors (boys and
girls) are
given the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery tests and
that recruiters then show up at their homes. Recruiters admit
their aggressive pursuit of students, even when parents object.
'The only thing that will get us to stop contacting the family
is if they call their congressman," says Major Johannes Paraan,
head army recruiter for Vermont and northeastern New York.
"People need to be alerted that these things are happening,"
says Jahnkow. 'The Pentagon is clearly influencing civilian life
and also attempting to plant seeds that would make the public
more accepting of the will of the military. What is happening in
our schools is like a draft in the making for our children."
Should We Take This Seriously?
Charles Moskos, Ph.D., of Northwestern University, military
adviser to U.S. presidents and secretaries of defense during his
nearly 40-year career, thinks we should. "I was recently in
Iraq, and there just aren't enough U.S. soldiers on the ground.
Military experts estimate we need double the numbers of troops
we currently have there-and we can't achieve that without a
draft.”
What You Can Do
1. Call the Capitol in Washington, D.C., (202-224-3121)
or go to the Web sites
http://www.house.gov and
http://www.senate.gov for your congressman's
address or e-mail. Write to him/her about your concern.
2. You are legally entitled to block your children's
names, address and phone number from being given to military
recruiters by their schools. To do this, mail a letter to the
school district headquarters (preferably by certified mail),
with a copy to the school principal, directing that no
information about your child be released to armed forces
representatives.